Scottsdale police arrest man in 2015 murder of Allison Feldman

Posted: Updated:
Ian Mitcham (left) arrested in connection to the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman (right). (Source: Maricopa County Sheriff's Office/3TV/CBS 5) Ian Mitcham (left) arrested in connection to the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman (right). (Source: Maricopa County Sheriff's Office/3TV/CBS 5)
Ian Mitcham, arrested in connection to the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Ian Mitcham, arrested in connection to the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
Ian Mitcham (Source: Maricopa County Sheriff's Office) Ian Mitcham (Source: Maricopa County Sheriff's Office)
SCOTTSDALE, AZ (3TV/CBS 5) -

"We never stopped investigating this case."

Scottsdale police have made an arrest in the 2015 murder of Allison Feldman.

Feldman, a 31-year-old medical sales rep, was murdered in her south Scottsdale home on Feb. 17, 2015.

Documents state she died from blunt force trauma and asphyxiation after being found by her boyfriend.

[ORIGINAL STORY: Police ID woman found dead in Scottsdale home (Feb. 18, 2015)]

Now, police have arrested 42-year-old Ian L. Mitcham on a first-degree murder charge.

He was taken to jail on Tuesday night and booked. His initial court appearance is scheduled for 5 a.m.

[RAW VIDEO: Perp walk of 2015 murder suspect from Scottsdale]

[RAW VIDEO: Ian Mitcham faces judge on murder, burglary charges]

"We are one hundred percent confident we have the right suspect," said Scottsdale Assistant Police Chief Scott Popp.

[RAW: Scottsdale police briefing on arrest in Allison Feldman murder]

A DNA sample found at the murder scene was linked to a sibling of the suspect already in prison, using a process called "familial DNA testing." 

"We collected over 400 items of evidence," said Popp. "We spent the next three years exhausting every lead... We've analyzed hundreds of items. We've conducted hundreds of interviews, and spent well over, 3-to-4 thousand personnel hours conducting this investigation."

[INTERACTIVE TIMELINE: 1,148 days from murder to arrest]

After several years with no leads, Scottsdale police contacted DPS, and the process of the "familial DNA match" began.

"Scottsdale PD found an unknown DNA sample at the crime scene. We compared that sample to our DNA database of arrested offenders here in Arizona," said Col. Frank Milstead of the Arizona Department of Public Safety. "We came up with a family linkage to this person who was in custody. And then, through that information, they were able to identify the sibling of that person in custody. The familial DNA is off siblings, parents in the same bloodline You inherit blood traits from your parents and that moves through the process."

"I'm elated that this guy has been caught," said Allison Feldman's father, Harley Feldman. "We wish wouldn't be here, but if we're here, we're glad he’s been caught by police."

Over the years, Feldman's family members had continued to share her story in hopes someone would have a key piece of information that would break the case.

[RELATED: Remembering Allison Feldman 3 years after her murder; case remains unsolved]

Friends and family had never given up hope the case would be solved.

"We knew it was the evidence that would lead to an arrest, and that’s essentially what happened," Harley Feldman said.

 "I really, firmly believe that this is going to be solved. I truly do. I know there's going to be justice for Ally," said Feldman's best friend, Katie McCartin at the time.

"We all have developed a deep connection to the Feldman family over the years," said Popp. Everything we know about Allison, she was a beautiful human being. There was no reason whatsoever Allison should have been the victim of a violent crime in our city."

[RELATED: Reward increases to $10K in Scottsdale murder case (June 14, 2015)]

[RELATED: Scottsdale woman's murder remains 'priority' for police]

Feldman worked as a medical sales rep in the Valley. Her boss, Jeff Ciardi, had described her as his little sister.

"It's extremely difficult to think it's been three years since she passed," he said. "I still feel the emotions I feel that same night three years ago... having to call her friends and tell them the tragic news."

Popp said Scottsdale police spoke to Feldman's father Tuesday afternoon. He said they share a feeling of relief. "We feel relief that the murderer is not on the street anymore."

[RELATED: Loved ones remember Allison Feldman, 2 years after her unsolved murder]

"Violent murder of a child is the biggest stress and trauma that the human body can ever go through," her mother, Elaine Feldman, had said at a candlelight vigil held in honor of her daughter.

Friends say Feldman had volunteered her time with young burn patients and was about to get engaged to her boyfriend.

"She was a loyal friend, a strong woman, vibrant, and full of life," said one of Feldman's close friends.

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

Copyright 2018 KPHO/KTVK (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.