Scottsdale Unified attorney: Former CFO violated state law

Posted: Updated:
While serving as CFO, Laura Smith signed off on thousands of dollars in payments to a consulting company owned by her sister. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) While serving as CFO, Laura Smith signed off on thousands of dollars in payments to a consulting company owned by her sister. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
The attorney presented a public summary of her findings Tuesday evening. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) The attorney presented a public summary of her findings Tuesday evening. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
Smith submitted a letter of resignation Friday in which she acknowledged “mistakenly” signing off on two payment-related documents to her former company. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Smith submitted a letter of resignation Friday in which she acknowledged “mistakenly” signing off on two payment-related documents to her former company. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
Superintendent Dr. Denise Birdwell said the district would provide a statement Wednesday. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Superintendent Dr. Denise Birdwell said the district would provide a statement Wednesday. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
SCOTTSDALE, AZ (3TV/CBS 5) -

The former chief financial officer of the Scottsdale Unified School District violated state laws regarding conflicts of interest along with district policy, according to the findings and legal opinion of an attorney hired by the district to investigate the case.

The attorney presented a public summary of her findings Tuesday evening after the SUSD Governing Board voted to accept the resignation of CFO Laura Smith.

While serving as CFO, Smith signed off on thousands of dollars in payments to a consulting company owned by her sister. Smith never identified her sister on conflict-of-interest disclosure forms and has failed to provide evidence showing she no longer has a financial stake in the company herself, according to attorney Susan Segal.

Segal said she submitted her findings to the Arizona Attorney General’s Office, which has launched investigations into the district. The district’s hiring of an unlicensed architect who was previously convicted of stealing public funds has also drawn scrutiny.

Smith submitted a letter of resignation Friday in which she acknowledged “mistakenly” signing off on two payment-related documents to her former company, Professional Group Public Consulting (PGPC). Smith said she also “inadvertently erred” by failing to disclose that the principal of PGPC is her sister, Caroline Brackley.

However, public records show Smith signed off on several other change orders that she did not acknowledge in her resignation letter. Smith personally signed a total of five change orders that boosted payments to PGPC by $16,072, Segal said.

Smith's computer-generated approval also appears on six purchase orders to PGPC totaling an additional $43,766, Segal said.

She said Smith began working as Scottsdale’s CFO on Feb. 15, 2017. In the resignation letter, Smith said PGPC “accepted [her] request” to buy out her interest in the company at the end of May.

“She has not provided evidence that the stock was actually sold or how much of her stock was sold” despite repeated requests, Segal said.

In the letter of resignation, Smith wrote that she “did not intentionally act to reward the Professional Group while serving as the district's chief financial officer."

She added, “My career has been devoted to helping school districts maximize financial resources to help our students. My single, honest mistake and two inadvertent errors are now being unfairly extrapolated into something sinister. It is not sinister nor dishonest.”

The Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board unanimously accepted the resignation. They also received the preliminary report from Segal, identifying the findings of her investigation, and authorized Segal to share her report in the open meeting.

Segal confirmed a conflict of interest existed with Smith, in violation of state statute. Per an outside expert, Segal confirmed that Dr. Birdwell would not have been aware of Smith's actions, nor was she directly involved.

In addition, Segal certified that Dr. Birdwell had cautioned against and instructed Smith not to approve change orders or payments to the company with which she was financially affiliated.

Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board President Barbara Perleberg released the following statement regarding the actions of Smith and the conclusion of the investigation.

A year ago, the Board identified the need to fix our broken systems in order to change the status quo. Those systems have plagued SUSD for decades. We chose to focus on the classroom and academic achievement first. While there have been strong gains in those areas, this investigation highlights the needs that exist in our back-office systems, as well. We will continue to strive to meet the challenges of serving the 23,000 students of SUSD with integrity and accountability each and every day.

As of Jan. 24, all open purchase orders involving PGPC have been closed at the direction of superintendent Dr. Denise Birdwell, said Segal.

Dr. Birdwell said that Smith will not receive a severance package as part of her resignation. In a statement, SUSD said the superintendent and governing board regret the distraction and distruct this event may have created and look forward to moving forward in a positive and transparent manner.

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

Copyright 2018 KPHO/KTVK (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.


Derek StaahlDerek Staahl is an Emmy Award-winning reporter and fill-in anchor who loves covering stories that matter most to Arizona families.

Click to learn more about Derek.

Derek Staahl

This once-uncompromising "California guy" got his first taste of Arizona in 2015 while covering spring training baseball for his former station. The trip spanned just three days, but Derek quickly decided Phoenix should be his next address. He joined CBS 5 and 3TV four months later, in August 2015. Before packing his bags for the Valley of the Sun, Derek spent nearly four years at XETV in San Diego, where he was promoted to Weekend Anchor and Investigative Reporter. Derek chaired the Saturday and Sunday 10 p.m. newscasts, which regularly earned the station's highest ratings for a news program each week. Derek’s investigative reporting efforts into the Mayor Bob Filner scandal in 2013 sparked a "governance crisis" for the city of San Diego and was profiled by the region’s top newspaper. Derek broke into the news business at WKOW-TV in Madison, WI. He wrote, shot, edited, and presented stories during the week, and produced newscasts on the weekends. By the end of his stint, he was promoted to part-time anchor on WKOW’s sister station, WMSN. Derek was born in Los Angeles and was named the “Undergraduate Broadcast Journalism Student of the Year” in his graduating class at USC. He also played quads in the school’s famous drumline. When not reporting the news, Derek enjoys playing drumset, sand volleyball, and baseball.

Hide bio