Allegations of test fixing leads to invalidated scores for some 3rd graders

Posted: Updated:
A handful of Valley third graders had their AzMerit Math Assessment results invalidated after the Arizona Department of Education found "test impropriety," according to a letter sent home to parents. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) A handful of Valley third graders had their AzMerit Math Assessment results invalidated after the Arizona Department of Education found "test impropriety," according to a letter sent home to parents. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
Abriana Sanchez said her teacher changed one of her answers after she turned in the test. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Abriana Sanchez said her teacher changed one of her answers after she turned in the test. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
The school at the center of this, Edupreneurship Student Center, or "ESC" as it's known, is a charter school in north Phoenix. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) The school at the center of this, Edupreneurship Student Center, or "ESC" as it's known, is a charter school in north Phoenix. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
We're told Abriana was not held back as a result of the allegations. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) We're told Abriana was not held back as a result of the allegations. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
PHOENIX (3TV/CBS 5) -

A handful of Valley third-graders had their AzMerit Math Assessment results invalidated after the Arizona Department of Education found "test impropriety," according to a letter sent home to parents.

The school at the center of this, Edupreneurship Student Center, or "ESC" as it's known, is a charter school in north Phoenix.

Abriana Sanchez was one of the students impacted. 

This is what she says happened after she turned in her assessment book to her teacher this past spring.

"She looked through it and said this isn't right and erased the bubbling and bubbled the right one and said I never taught you this yet," Abriana said.

The allegations came up when Abriana's mom was asking her brother about how his testing went.

"I called the Department of Education and they investigated and that made the principal, then have to do an investigation," Apryl Gastelum, Abriana's mother said.

The head of ESC sent a letter to the parents of the students affected by the allegations that the teacher erased answers and changed them, which says in part, "the state felt that there was enough evidence to invalidate the assessment."

We reached out to the head of the school but did not hear back Tuesday. A spokesperson with the Arizona Department of Education says they cannot comment or even confirm any potential or ongoing investigations.

"It's upsetting to see that my daughter's third-grade year was really sabotaged, I don't know, is she ready for fourth grade?" asked Gastelum.

We're told Abriana was not held back as a result of this.

The school did say in the letter that, "This does not mean that your child failed this assessment because we know their ability and have other means of assessment we use here as ESC."

Still, Gastelum said she'd had enough and pulled both her kids out of ESC, enrolling them in a new charter school, much to their delight.

"I'm in a way better school," Abriana said.

Her mom is also keeping close tabs on what's going on in the new classrooms, saying she's doing what she can to keep this from happening again.

Even though the head of the school did not get back to us, she said in the letter they sent home to parents that disciplinary actions are being taken and that it will be brought to the board adding, "this is a serious violation and we are following policy and procedure on this matter." 

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

Copyright 2017 KPHO/KTVK (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.


Amanda GoodmanAmanda Goodman joined Arizona’s Family in May 2014.

Click to learn more about Amanda.

Amanda Goodman

The Yuma native and ASU Walter Cronkite School graduate is delighted to be back home in Arizona.

Goodman started her career in St. George, Utah, working at an independent station. While there, she was able to do a little bit of everything from reporting to anchoring to shooting her own video and even producing.

From there, she headed east to West Virginia, working at the No. 1 station in the Huntington, Charleston market, WSAZ-TV.

Before returning to Arizona, Goodman spent the past three years at KRQE-TV in Albuquerque. During her time there, she covered many high-profile, stories including the murder trial of a former Albuquerque police officer, the Las Conchas wildfire that threatened Los Alamos National Lab, and the massive Wallow Fire that made its way into New Mexico from Arizona.

When she’s not reporting and tweeting, Goodman spends a lot of her free time hanging out with family and friends.

She also loves to travel and has been to four, soon to be five, continents.

Goodman is so excited to be back home and can’t wait to share some of your stories.

Hide bio

  • Featured VideoMore>>

  • California activists want to send nuclear waste to Palo Verde

    California activists want to send nuclear waste to Palo Verde

    Saturday, November 18 2017 2:02 PM EST2017-11-18 19:02:41 GMT
    (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)(Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    San Onofre State Beach is a kind of hidden gem among surfers. But there is something about the view here that looks just a little out of place. It’s a nuclear power plant, right on the beach. Some activists want to send the nuclear waste that's housed at San Onofre to Arizona.

    More >

    San Onofre State Beach is a kind of hidden gem among surfers. But there is something about the view here that looks just a little out of place. It’s a nuclear power plant, right on the beach. Some activists want to send the nuclear waste that's housed at San Onofre to Arizona.

    More >
  • Tuesday @ 9 p.m. on 3TV: Flooded cars in Arizona

    Tuesday @ 9 p.m. on 3TV: Flooded cars in Arizona

    Thousands of flooded hurricane cars are already in Arizona. Can viewers spot the red flags of a water-logged wreck? 3 On Your Side puts them to the test - Tuesday at 9 p.m. on 3TV.

    More >

    Thousands of flooded hurricane cars are already in Arizona. Can viewers spot the red flags of a water-logged wreck? 3 On Your Side puts them to the test - Tuesday at 9 p.m. on 3TV.

    More >
  • Up to $15K stolen after card skimmer used on Chandler ATM

    Saturday, November 18 2017 1:47 AM EST2017-11-18 06:47:04 GMT
    (Source: Chandler Police Department)(Source: Chandler Police Department)

    Chandler Police are investigating after a card skimmer was apparently installed on a bank ATM to gather customer account information.  Investigators say the Arizona Bank and Trust drive-up ATM near I-10 and Ray Road was targeted.

    More >

    Chandler Police are investigating after a card skimmer was apparently installed on a bank ATM to gather customer account information.  Investigators say the Arizona Bank and Trust drive-up ATM near I-10 and Ray Road was targeted.

    More >