Publicist says Joe Arpaio wouldn't have violated court order

Posted: Updated:
Joe Arpaio was back in court for day two of his criminal contempt trial where his longtime publicist testified. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Joe Arpaio was back in court for day two of his criminal contempt trial where his longtime publicist testified. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

Former Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio's longtime Director of Media Relations testified at her ex-boss' criminal trial Tuesday that he wouldn't have violated a judge's order to stop traffic patrols targeting illegal immigrants.

Lisa Allen, chief spokeswoman and confidant for the lawman for nearly 23 years, said Arpaio's earlier career as a federal drug agent taught him respect for the orders of federal courts. "He was a federal guy," Allen said. "He knew what to do if there was a court order."

Allen testified on the second day of Arpaio's trial on a misdemeanor contempt-of-court charge for continuing the traffic patrols 17 months after a judge in a racial profiling lawsuit ordered them stopped.

[RELATED: Former Sheriff Joe Arpaio heads to 2nd day of criminal trial]

Arpaio, the former six-term sheriff of metro Phoenix, has acknowledged prolonging the patrols, but said his disobedience wasn't intentional.

Prosecutors must prove that Arpaio purposefully violated the order to win a conviction. They cited a news release that came after the 2011 order in which Arpaio said he'd continue to enforce illegal immigration laws. They also read an excerpt from a March 2012 TV interview in which Arpaio said his officers were still detaining immigrants who were in the country illegally.

[RELATED: Prosecutors use Joe Arpaio's immigration talk against him]

The 85-year-old Arpaio would face up to six months in jail if convicted, though lawyers who have followed the case doubt he would ever be incarcerated.

Earlier Tuesday, an attorney who defended Arpaio for nearly six years in the profiling case testified that his client's growing resistance to court orders led him to step down as Arpaio's attorney. Tim Casey cited attorney-client privilege in declining to provide specific details.

"Until there was criminal contempt, there was never an issue with the sheriff and I about me doing my job," Casey said.

Under cross-examination from Arpaio's current attorney, Dennis Wilenchek, blamed Casey for not making it clear to Arpaio and everyone inside the Sheriff's organization what the judge's order said and how best to follow it.

"It's clear from the emails he dropped the ball whether he agrees with it or not I don't really care. He's the one who dropped the ball not the sheriff not anyone else," said Wilenchek after Tuesday's proceeding.

[RELATED: Former Sheriff Joe Arpaio to face day of reckoning in court]

Arpaio showed no facial expression as Casey testified.

The contempt case is believed to have contributed to Arpaio's election defeat in November by retired Phoenix police Sgt. Paul Penzone.

[RELATED: 'America's toughest sheriff' says 'I did it my way']

The judge in the profiling case had concluded that Arpaio violated the order because the sheriff believed continuing his immigration efforts would benefit his 2012 re-election campaign.

Allen was asked whether Arpaio issued news releases for political gain. "My interest wasn't political," Allen said. "My interest was providing information to the news media."

Prosecutors then showed a video clip from a 2014 documentary about Arpaio in which Allen said the sheriff was addicted to the media and had "a stream of narcissism to him." She also said in the film that Arpaio's media attention gives him power.

[READ MORE: Judge recommends criminal prosecution of Arpaio in racial profiling case (Aug. 19, 2016)]

Allen said Tuesday she urged Arpaio to scale back on the number of news releases he made about his immigration efforts, saying reporters were being bombarded with information. She said she usually lost those arguments.

"He wanted everyone to know what he was doing," Allen said.

[RELATED: Ex-sheriff Joe Arpaio loses bid to bar campaign comments at trial]

Critics hope the trial in federal court in Phoenix will bring a long-awaited comeuppance for the defiant Arpaio, who escaped accountability while leading crackdowns that divided immigrant families.

It's not known whether Arpaio will testify in his defense.

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

© 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.