Why Phoenix doesn't have a hot weather 'stupid hiker law'

Posted: Updated:
Hiking in Arizona (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Hiking in Arizona (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
PHOENIX (3TV/CBS 5) -

Arizonans experience the extreme heat every summer, with temperatures crawling toward 120 degrees. 

Yet, the Phoenix hiking trails remain open.

[RELATED: Just say NO to hiking in the extreme heat]

While hiking is popular in the Valley, trails can be dangerous, even deadly, when it comes to extreme heat.

Arizona has the "Stupid Motorist Law," but why hasn't there been a "Stupid Hiker Law?"

The main reason is that first responders don’t want people to be afraid of the consequences of calling 911 for help.

[RELATED: Could law deter people from hiking in extreme heat?]

Secondly, it's not logistically feasible to enforce such a law. Robert Mann from Radix Law says that a "Stupid Hiker Law" is just not possible from a law enforcement standpoint.

Supporters of such a law have called for it to be modeled after the "Stupid Motorist Law."  However, with the stupid motorist law, drivers are required to pay for their rescue only after they have driven around a barrier and onto flooded streets.

[RELATED: At least 4 hikers died during record heat in Arizona - June 19, 2016]

There are hundreds of hiking trails with multiple entry and exit points in the Phoenix area. It would be impossible to close trails and put up physical barriers on all of those trails. There is no way to regulate traffic at every point.

[RELATED: Southwest celebrates first day of summer with heat wave]

Mann says that the problem is not consistent enough for a law to be enacted. 

In 2016, the Phoenix Parks and Recreation board rejected a proposal to ban hiking in extreme heat. 

[SPECIAL SECTION: Extreme Heat]

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

Copyright 2017 KPHO/KTVK (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.


  • Featured VideoMore>>

  • Triano gets win in interim coaching debut for Phoenix

    Triano gets win in interim coaching debut for Phoenix

    Tuesday, October 24 2017 1:32 AM EDT2017-10-24 05:32:25 GMT
    Phoenix Suns head coach Jay Triano speaks with Phoenix Suns guard Troy Daniels (30) during the first half of an NBA basketball game against the Sacramento Kings, Monday, Oct. 23, 2017, in Phoenix. (Source: AP Photo/Matt York)Phoenix Suns head coach Jay Triano speaks with Phoenix Suns guard Troy Daniels (30) during the first half of an NBA basketball game against the Sacramento Kings, Monday, Oct. 23, 2017, in Phoenix. (Source: AP Photo/Matt York)

    The Phoenix Suns beat the Sacramento Kings 117-115 on Monday for their first win of the season in their first game under interim coach Jay Triano.

    More >

    The Phoenix Suns beat the Sacramento Kings 117-115 on Monday for their first win of the season in their first game under interim coach Jay Triano.

    More >
  • Education board votes to review new grading system

    Education board votes to review new grading system

    Tuesday, October 24 2017 1:25 AM EDT2017-10-24 05:25:37 GMT
    The Arizona Board of Education decided to delay issuing final grades to schools in state. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)The Arizona Board of Education decided to delay issuing final grades to schools in state. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    As soon as the grades were released earlier this month, the new system was bombarded with criticism that the data used was inaccurate. 

    More >

    As soon as the grades were released earlier this month, the new system was bombarded with criticism that the data used was inaccurate. 

    More >
  • 3 On Your Side

    Comparing Halloween candy prices

    Comparing Halloween candy prices

    Tuesday, October 24 2017 12:53 AM EDT2017-10-24 04:53:15 GMT
    3 On Your Side compared different candy bags to see which had the best bang for the buck. (Source: 3TV)3 On Your Side compared different candy bags to see which had the best bang for the buck. (Source: 3TV)

    How much will you spend on Halloween this year? For the answer, we sent our 3 On Your Side crew out to do a little comparison shopping and have a little fun.

    More >

    How much will you spend on Halloween this year? For the answer, we sent our 3 On Your Side crew out to do a little comparison shopping and have a little fun.

    More >