Why Phoenix doesn't have a hot weather 'stupid hiker law'

Posted: Updated:
Hiking in Arizona (Source: 3TV/CBS 5) Hiking in Arizona (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
PHOENIX (3TV/CBS 5) -

Arizonans experience the extreme heat every summer, with temperatures crawling toward 120 degrees. 

Yet, the Phoenix hiking trails remain open.

[RELATED: Just say NO to hiking in the extreme heat]

While hiking is popular in the Valley, trails can be dangerous, even deadly, when it comes to extreme heat.

Arizona has the "Stupid Motorist Law," but why hasn't there been a "Stupid Hiker Law?"

The main reason is that first responders don’t want people to be afraid of the consequences of calling 911 for help.

[RELATED: Could law deter people from hiking in extreme heat?]

Secondly, it's not logistically feasible to enforce such a law. Robert Mann from Radix Law says that a "Stupid Hiker Law" is just not possible from a law enforcement standpoint.

Supporters of such a law have called for it to be modeled after the "Stupid Motorist Law."  However, with the stupid motorist law, drivers are required to pay for their rescue only after they have driven around a barrier and onto flooded streets.

[RELATED: At least 4 hikers died during record heat in Arizona - June 19, 2016]

There are hundreds of hiking trails with multiple entry and exit points in the Phoenix area. It would be impossible to close trails and put up physical barriers on all of those trails. There is no way to regulate traffic at every point.

[RELATED: Southwest celebrates first day of summer with heat wave]

Mann says that the problem is not consistent enough for a law to be enacted. 

In 2016, the Phoenix Parks and Recreation board rejected a proposal to ban hiking in extreme heat. 

[SPECIAL SECTION: Extreme Heat]

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

Copyright 2017 KPHO/KTVK (KPHO Broadcasting Corporation). All rights reserved.


  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Officers kill man with no active warrants at wrong house

    Officers kill man with no active warrants at wrong house

    Wednesday, July 26 2017 7:40 AM EDT2017-07-26 11:40:11 GMT
    (Source: Family)(Source: Family)

    Documents show that Southaven officers went to the wrong house to serve a warrant on Monday, which resulted in the shooting death of a man who did not have any active warrants out for his arrest.

    More >

    Documents show that Southaven officers went to the wrong house to serve a warrant on Monday, which resulted in the shooting death of a man who did not have any active warrants out for his arrest.

    More >
  • Records: Child's body decomposing on arrival at hospital

    Records: Child's body decomposing on arrival at hospital

    Thursday, July 27 2017 2:31 PM EDT2017-07-27 18:31:39 GMT
    (Cory Morse/The Grand Rapids Press via AP).(Cory Morse/The Grand Rapids Press via AP).

    The body of a 6-month-old western Michigan boy had already started to decompose by the time his mother took him to a hospital after she had basically ignored him for two days in her sweltering home with no air conditioning, according to court records.

    More >

    The body of a 6-month-old western Michigan boy had already started to decompose by the time his mother took him to a hospital after she had basically ignored him for two days in her sweltering home with no air conditioning, according to court records.

    More >
  • Thrill ride was OK'd hours before deadly state fair accident

    Thrill ride was OK'd hours before deadly state fair accident

    Friday, July 28 2017 12:53 AM EDT2017-07-28 04:53:40 GMT
    The Ohio State Fair will be open Thursday, a day after one person was killed and seven others were injured when an "aggressive thrill" ride broke apart.More >
    The Ohio State Fair will be open Thursday, a day after one person was killed and seven others were injured when an "aggressive thrill" ride broke apart.More >
  • Featured VideoMore>>

  • Family celebrates life of officer killed 10 years ago

    Family celebrates life of officer killed 10 years ago

    Friday, July 28 2017 3:19 AM EDT2017-07-28 07:19:25 GMT
    For Tiffany Cortez and her family, July 27 will always be a tough day. Ten years ago her husband and the father of her children, Phoenix Police Officer George Cortez was shot and killed on the job. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)For Tiffany Cortez and her family, July 27 will always be a tough day. Ten years ago her husband and the father of her children, Phoenix Police Officer George Cortez was shot and killed on the job. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    For Tiffany Cortez and her family, July 27 will always be a tough day. Ten years ago her husband and the father of her children, Phoenix Police Officer George Cortez was shot and killed on the job.

    More >

    For Tiffany Cortez and her family, July 27 will always be a tough day. Ten years ago her husband and the father of her children, Phoenix Police Officer George Cortez was shot and killed on the job.

    More >
  • Truck full of Christmas decorations stolen from Scottsdale store

    Truck full of Christmas decorations stolen from Scottsdale store

    Friday, July 28 2017 3:17 AM EDT2017-07-28 07:17:58 GMT
    The stolen truck was recovered, but all the contents were gone. (Source: Paul Folk)The stolen truck was recovered, but all the contents were gone. (Source: Paul Folk)

    We're months away from Christmas but it seems a Grinch has already tried to steal it. Someone ripped off a truck loaded with holiday decorations from a valley home decor shop.

    More >

    We're months away from Christmas but it seems a Grinch has already tried to steal it. Someone ripped off a truck loaded with holiday decorations from a valley home decor shop.

    More >
  • 3 On Your Side

    Valley reality TV star says she was duped for $175,000

    Valley reality TV star says she was duped for $175,000

    Friday, July 28 2017 3:17 AM EDT2017-07-28 07:17:14 GMT
    Kira Girard contacted 3 On Your Side complaining that Tom Greenwald left her home unsafe and in disrepair. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)Kira Girard contacted 3 On Your Side complaining that Tom Greenwald left her home unsafe and in disrepair. (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    Valley reality TV star says she handed over $175,000 to remodel her home but in the end, she said the job was botched and her home was left unsafe.

    More >

    Valley reality TV star says she handed over $175,000 to remodel her home but in the end, she said the job was botched and her home was left unsafe.

    More >