Ex-sheriff Joe Arpaio loses bid to bar campaign comments at trial

Posted: Updated:
(Source: 3TV/CBS 5) (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)
PHOENIX (AP) -

Prosecutors at former Sheriff Joe Arpaio's upcoming criminal trial over his refusal to stop his immigration patrols can use campaign statements he made about his fight against border problems, a judge has ruled.

U.S. District Judge Susan Bolton on Wednesday rejected the retired metro Phoenix lawman's argument that such comments would be prejudicial and have a chilling effect on protected speech.

She ruled Arpaio didn't offer any legal authority to back up the notion that campaign comments can't be used against a defendant at a criminal trial.

"The Constitution does not prohibit defendant's campaign statements as evidence," Bolton wrote.

Arpaio is scheduled to go on trial June 26 in federal court on a criminal contempt of court charge for prolonging his immigration patrols for 17 months after another judge in a racial profiling case had ordered them stopped.

The judge in the profiling case had ruled that Arpaio ignored the order because he believed the enforcement efforts would help his 2012 campaign.

Arpaio, who was ousted last year after six terms in office, has acknowledged prolonging the patrols but insists his disobedience wasn't intentional. If convicted of the misdemeanor charge, the 84-year-old Arpaio could face up to six months in jail.

For nine years, he enjoyed solid popularity by locking up immigrants who were in the United States illegally and regularly told news reporters that no one would stop his crackdowns.

His fight against illegal immigration was a fixture of his stump speeches and media interviews during his last three campaigns.

An attorney for Arpaio had argued that such remarks about immigration were campaign posturing and not made under oath and that his client made the statements during his races to bolster his reputation for being tough on illegal immigration.

Bolton on Wednesday also rejected Arpaio's request to prohibit the testimony of two people who were illegally detained as part of the prolonged patrols.

Arpaio's attorneys had argued that allowing such victims to testify would be irrelevant in determining whether he had committed a crime.

Prosecutors said the victim testimony should be heard at trial because they are evidence of Arpaio's guilt.

Arpaio has tried unsuccessfully to have a jury, rather than Bolton, decide whether he is guilty.

Last week, he asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider his request for a jury trial. The nation's highest court hasn't yet responded.

Click/tap here to download the free azfamily mobile app.

© 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.


  • Most Popular StoriesMost Popular StoriesMore>>

  • Some say no to eclipse viewing, Navajo tradition forbids

    Thursday, August 17 2017 11:45 PM EDT2017-08-18 03:45:08 GMT
    Some Native Americans won't be looking at the eclipse on Monday. (Source: CNN)Some Native Americans won't be looking at the eclipse on Monday. (Source: CNN)

    Monday is the big day! For the first time in decades, a total solar eclipse will jog over the United States. Not everyone is going to head outside, though, with protective glasses to get a peek. 

    More >

    Monday is the big day! For the first time in decades, a total solar eclipse will jog over the United States. Not everyone is going to head outside, though, with protective glasses to get a peek. 

    More >
  • Remains of Natalee Holloway may have been discovered

    Remains of Natalee Holloway may have been discovered

    Thursday, August 17 2017 1:55 PM EDT2017-08-17 17:55:09 GMT
    It has been 12 long years, but the case of Natalee Holloway, the woman who went missing in 2005, might be one step closer to closing.It has been 12 long years, but the case of Natalee Holloway, the woman who went missing in 2005, might be one step closer to closing.

    It has been 12 long years, but the case of Natalee Holloway, the woman who went missing in 2005, might be one step closer to closing.

    More >

    It has been 12 long years, but the case of Natalee Holloway, the woman who went missing in 2005, might be one step closer to closing.

    More >
  • 3 On Your Side

    Can your HOA issue you a speeding ticket?

    Can your HOA issue you a speeding ticket?

    Friday, August 18 2017 11:03 AM EDT2017-08-18 15:03:29 GMT
    (Source: 3TV/CBS 5)(Source: 3TV/CBS 5)

    Sun Lakes is in the East Valley and is known for having active adult communities for retirees like Bernie Van Emden. "You name it, they got it here,” Van Emden said of all of the amenities in his development.

    More >

    Sun Lakes is in the East Valley and is known for having active adult communities for retirees like Bernie Van Emden. "You name it, they got it here,” Van Emden said of all of the amenities in his development.

    More >